MTS Systems Logo Contact Us
  • Industries
    • Automotive
      • Passenger Cars & Light Trucks
      • Driver Assisted & Autonomous Vehicles
      • Electric & New Energy Vehicles
      • Heavy Trucks & Commercial Vehicles
      • Off-Highway Vehicles (OHV)
      • Racing & Motorsports
      • Recreational Vehicles
      • Motorcycles
      Automotive

      Automotive

      320 kph

      flat-belt roadway enables precise replication of motorsports cornering maneuvers

      Read the Case Study
    • Materials
      • Metals
      • Composites
      • Plastics
      • Rubber & Elastomers
      • Adhesives
      • Concrete & Rock
      • Ceramics & Glass
      • Textiles
      • Wood
      • Paper Products
      • Universities
      Materials

      Materials

      1500 degree Celsius

      solutions for testing high-temperature alloys, composites, ceramics and polymers

      Read the Article
    • Aerospace
      • Fixed Wing Aircraft
      • Helicopters & Rotary Wing Aircraft
      • UAM (Urban Air Mobility)
      • Delivery Drones
      • Supersonic Aircraft
      • Space Structures
      Aerospace

      Aerospace

      20% increase

      in testing speeds using state-of-the-art cross-coupling compensation technology

      Read the Article
    • Biomedical
      • Orthopedic
      • Medical Devices
      • Dental
      • Hospitals & Universities
      Biomedical

      Biomedical

      1 in 1,000 children

      will need corrective scoliosis surgery

      Read the Case Study
    • Civil Engineering
      • Multi-Hazard Engineering
      • Seismic Engineering
      • Structural Engineering
      Civil Engineering

      Civil Engineering

      1.32 million pound

      force capacity enables the testing of very large specimens all the way to failure

      Read the Case Study
    • Rock Geomechanics
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Geothermal Energy
      • Mining
      • Construction
      • Carbon Sequestration
      • Research
      Rock Geomechanics

      Rock & Geomechanics

      3x stronger

      concrete materials make it possible to carry higher loads

      Read the Case Study
    • Energy
      • Wind Energy
      • Oil & Gas
      Energy

      Energy

      56 MNm

      overturning moment capacity enables testing of the largest wind turbine drivetrains

      Read the Article
    • Rail
      • Commuter Trains
      • Freight Trains
      • High-Speed Trains
      Rail

      Rail

      550 kph

      test system enables lab-based studies of high-speed rail operating environments

      Read the Article
  • Applications
    • Materials Applications
    • Test Type
      • Tension
      • Compression
      • Fatigue & Fracture
      • Flexure & Bend
      • Shear, Peel & Tear
      • Torsion
      • Non-Contacting Strain Measurement
      • High Temperature
      • Bi-Axial & Multi-Axial
      • High Rate
      • Dynamic Mechanical Analysis

      Material Applications by Material

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Test Standard
      • ASTM Test Standards
      • ISO Test Standards
      • EN Test Standards

      Material Applications by Material

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Materials
      • Metals
      • Composites
      • Plastics
      • Rubber & Elastomers
      • Adhesives
      • Fasteners & Welds
      • Concrete & Rock
      • Ceramics & Glass
      • Wood & Paper Products
      • Additive Manufacturing

      Material Applications by Material

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Automotive Applications
      • Full Vehicle
      • Axle & Suspension
      • Steering System
      • Drivetrain
      • Dampers
      • Elastomeric Mounts & Bushings
      • Tires
      • Exhaust System
      • Body Mounted Components
      • Cooling System Components
      • Transportation & Packaging
      • Motorcycle
      • Farm, Construction, Off-Highway Vehicles (OHV)

      Automotive

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Aerospace Applications
      • Complete Full-Scale Structures
      • Sub-Assemblies
      • Sub-Systems
      • Flight Control Systems
      • Airframe Components
      • Rotary-Wing Components
      • Gas Turbine Component Fatigue

      Aerospace

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Biomedical Applications
      • Orthopedic
      • Biomechanic
      • Medical Device
      • Biomaterial

      Biomedical

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Civil Engineering Applications
      • Civil Structures
      • Structural Sub-Assemblies & Components
      • Non-Structural Systems
      • Oil Rig Stay Cables
      • Construction Materials

      Civil Engineering

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Energy Applications
      • Wind Turbine Testing
      • Oil & Gas Pipeline

      Energy

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Rock Geomechanics Applications
      • Fossil Fuels
      • Geothermal
      • Nuclear Waste Storage

      Rock Geomechanics

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Rail Applications
      • Rail Car Suspension Components
      • Rail Car Coupler
      • Rail Car Wheels & Rail
      • Rail Car Axles
      • Rail Car Bogies
      • Complete Rail Cars
      • Rail Car Pantographs
      • Railway Track & Road Bed
      • Catenary & Trolley Wire

      Rail

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

  • Products
    • Automotive Systems
      • Full Vehicle Test Systems
      • Subsystem & Component Test Systems
      • Tire Test Systems
      • Damper Test Systems
      • Elastomer Test Systems
      • Hybrid Simulation Solutions
      • Modular Components

      Automotive

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Materials Test Systems
      • Static Materials Test Systems
      • Dynamic Materials Test Systems
      • Extensometers
      • Grips
      • Fixtures & Platens
      • Furnaces, Chambers & Fluid Baths
      • High Temp Subsystems & TMF
      • Load Cells / Force Transducers

      Materials

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Aerospace Systems
      • Turnkey Control & Data Acquisition
      • Turnkey Hydromechanical Power Distribution
      • Test Article Safety Solutions
      • Series 261 Structural Pressure Test Controller
      • High Force Test Systems
      • Modular Components
      • FlexDAC Data Acquisition Systems

      Aerospace

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Biomedical Systems
      • Orthopedic Test Systems
      • Biomechanic Test Systems
      • Medical Device Test Systems
      • Biomaterial Test Systems

      Biomedical

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Civil Engineering Systems
      • Seismic Simulators & Shake Tables
      • Multi-Axial Subassemblage Structural Test Systems
      • Hybrid Simulation Solutions
      • Seismic Isolation Bearing Test Systems
      • High-Force Test Systems
      • Modular Components
      • STEX Pro Software

      Civil Engineering

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Energy Systems
      • Wind Turbine Blade Fatigue Test Systems
      • Wind Turbine Blade Static Test Systems
      • Wind Turbine Blade Rain Erosion Test System
      • Wind Turbine Bearing & Drivetrain Test Systems
      • Oil & Gas Pipe / Coupling Test Systems
      • High-Force Test Systems
      • Modular Components

      Energy

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Rock & Geomechanics Systems
      • Rock Mechanics Test Systems
      • Polyaxial Rock Test System

      Rock Geomechanics

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Rail Systems
      • Air Spring Test System
      • Railway Damper Test System
      • Rolling Contact Fatigue (RCF) System
      • 4-28 Channel Bogie Frame Test System
      • Bogie Vibration & Characterization System
      • Pantograph Wear & Performance System
      • High-Force Test Systems
      • Damper Durability Test Systems
      • Elastomer Test Systems
      • Modular Components

      Rail

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Test System Components
      • Actuators & Servo-Valves
      • SilentFlo™ Hydraulic Power Units
      • 295 Hydraulic Service Manifolds
      • Stands & Frames
      • Load Bearing Components
      • FlexTest® Controllers
      • FlexDAC Data Acquisition
      • SWIFT® Evo Wheel Force Transducers

      Test System Components

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

    • Software & Monitoring
      • RPC® Connect Software
      • TestSuite™ Software
      • AeroPro™ Software
      • STEX™ Pro Software
      • Elastomer Testing Software
      • Damper Testing Software
      • MultiPurpose TestWare® (MPT)
      • First Road Interact Software
      • Multi-Pump Control Manager
      • Equipment Monitoring

      Software & Monitoring

      Solution Finder

      Search by Test Material, Test Type, or Test Standard to find relevant products fast.

  • Services
    • Services
      • Calibrations & Metrology
      • Consulting & Engineering Services
      • Equipment Monitoring
      • Routine Maintenance & Fluid Care
      • Repairs & Remanufacture
      • Relocation Services

      Services & Support

    • Plans
      • Software Support Plans
      • Technical Support Plans
      • Service Plans
      • Extended Warranty

      Services & Support

    • Training

      Training Courses

    • Parts

      Parts

    • Support

      myMTS Portal

  • Company
    • Our Company
      • About MTS
      • Global Presence
      • History

      Our Company

    • Careers

      Careers

    • Sustainability

      Sustainability

    • Suppliers
      • Supplier Home
      • Products & Services

      Suppliers

  • Solution Finder
  • Contact Us
  • R&D Test Systems
  • E2M Technologies
  • myMTS Portal
  • Global Sites
  • Search
Home > Verifying Turbine Service Life Predictions

Empa: Verifying Turbine Service Life Predictions with TMF

tmf testing
Empa’s TMF testing methodology requires a test system that can switch from mechanical strain control to load control within the same cycle, while superimposing high-frequency vibrations.

CUSTOMER CHALLENGE

Today’s gas and steam turbine designs are solving challenges that did not exist a few decades ago. Higher efficiency requires higher operating temperatures and materials that can resist oxidation and creep under these conditions. More flexible duty cycles mean these materials must also resist damage from thermomechanical fatigue. Of course, all of these improvements must be made without compromising operating costs or reliability.


To reach these goals, design philosophies are changing. As a result, conventional service life estimation methodologies are no longer always the best choice for accurately predicting the service life of turbine components. New methodologies are needed, but they must be tested and verified before manufacturers and end-users can trust them.

One lab that is pioneering developments in this field is Empa, a Swiss federal research institute located in Dübendorf, near Zurich. Using an innovative approach to thermomechanical fatigue (TMF) testing, Empa researchers are able to simulate close-to-actual turbine operating conditions with high fidelity and verify the effectiveness of new prediction methodologies.

tmf testing

Researchers use TMF technologies to effectively predict turbine service life.

“TMF testing has traditionally been used for material characterization,” said Dr. Stuart Holdsworth, Group Head of the High Temperature Integrity Group at Empa. “We are using the results of such tests to also form the basis of advanced material deformation and damage modeling concepts and, most importantly, for benchmarking the effectiveness of new high-temperature assessment procedures for predicting component lifetimes.”

Components within new turbines are designed to run as hot as possible — and thus as efficiently as possible — but not so hot that constituent materials exceed property limits. To avoid premature failure at high temperatures, it is necessary to fully account for time-dependent damage processes such as creep and oxidation, and their interaction effects on fatigue damage accumulation.

Simple creep or creep-fatigue studies focus on how materials react when controlled at steady high load and a high temperature. But this does not accurately reflect actual turbine service duty, in which loads and temperatures fluctuate.

“With the increasing tendency towards two-shift operation in the 1990s, and the subsequent increased adoption of combined cycle units, there has been an increased requirement for more flexible operation and the customer turbine start/stop number expectation,” Holdsworth said. “Today, the requirements are even more demanding.”

In the same way, duty cycles for jet engines are changing. Engines used in short-haul and regional aircraft experience shorter times between takeoff and touchdown. The shorter wings and narrower bodies of these aircraft mean that the engines encounter much different vibratory stress conditions than engines in larger, long-haul aircraft.

Because of this ever-changing array of duty cycles, it is difficult for turbine manufacturers to confidently predict how long each turbine component will last. Knowing the “weakest link” allows manufacturers to optimize new designs for reliability, and establish efficient maintenance schedules that focus on potential points of vulnerability.

This is why Holdsworth and his team devised an innovative approach to high temperature turbine component assessment, involving nonlinear finite element analysis and creep-fatigue damage analysis, as well as an effective means to benchmark and verify predictions.

The analysis technique follows an iterative process, starting with an initial creep fatigue assessment of specific turbine components. Advanced nonlinear finite element analysis is used to determine stress/strain states and critical locations in these components during service duty. Based on this information, the team can then make predictions about the component’s life span.

To determine the accuracy of these predictions, Holdsworth’s team developed a TMF testing methodology that can replicate the service cycle with the same thermal and mechanical stress/strain states that were identified in the initial analysis on the actual component. This process is then repeated, with results used to refine the analysis procedure until it is verified to predict service life accurately.

MTS SOLUTION

To perform its tests, the Empa laboratory uses two servohydraulic test systems from MTS capable of running complex TMF tests. The capabilities of these systems, their accessories, and their digital controller and software architectures accommodate two unique aspects of Empa’s approach to TMF testing.


The first is the ability to reproduce the critical location stress/strain states of the component under actual turbine operating conditions. To do this, the test must switch from mechanical strain control to load control within the same cycle, which requires unprecedented flexibility. Advanced compensation techniques provide the precise servovalve control necessary to switch control modes. In addition, MTS TestSuite™ software allows operators to create highly customized wave shapes that incorporate the proper sequence of ramps and holds, as well as create a single, multi-segment cycle with two separate control modes.

tmf testing

MTS TestSuite software allows test designers to create customized wave shapes.

The second is the ability to superimpose high-frequency vibrations upon relatively low-frequency cyclic stress/strain conditions to simulate, for example, the gas bending loads on turbine aerofoils superimposed on cyclic centrifugal loading. The variation in gas pressure on the aerofoil is due to the cyclic interaction of moving and stationary blades, while the cyclic centrifugal loading is a consequence of the operating duty conditions of the turbine. Again, the control architecture of the MTS test solution delivers the processing speed and programming flexibility required to add these vibrations to the TMF test and create a highly realistic simulation.

CUSTOMER BENEFITS

The ultimate beneficiaries of Empa’s unique approach to TMF testing are manufacturers of gas and steam turbine components and structures, as well as the aircraft and power plant operators who deploy them. Because Empa can now generate and verify more accurate service life predictions that align with how turbines will actually be operated, manufacturers can develop and optimize new designs with confidence, and end-users can be equally confident the turbines will meet their requirements for performance, reliability, efficiency and safety.

TMF

Learn more about thermomechanical fatigue testing solutions

TMF Solutions
Also of Interest:
  • Extensometers >
  • Materials Compression Test Applications >
  • Astm Test Standards >
Stay Connected
  • INDUSTRIES
  • Automotive
  • Materials
  • Aerospace
  • Biomedical
  • Civil Engineering
  • Rock Geomechanics
  • Energy
  • Rail
  • SALES & SUPPORT
  • Sales Offices
  • Services
  • Training
  • Parts
  • Customer Portal
  • SUPPLIERS
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Products & Services
  • Expectations
  • Workmanship Standards
  • Packaging & Labeling
  • Routing Guide
  • COMPANY
  • About
  • News
  • Careers
  • Culture
  • Sustainability
  • History
  • SOLUTIONS
  • Applications
  • Test Standards
  • Products
  • RESOURCES
  • Learning Center
  • Solution Finder
  • Quality
  • Product Safety
  • Patents
  • CONTACT US
  • SUPPORT: 952-937-4000
  • Online Request
  • Request A Quote
  • Sales Offices
  • BUSINESSES
  • MTS Systems
  • E2M Technologies
  • R&D Test Systems
  • MTS SANS China
    • © MTS Systems. All Rights Reserved
    • 952.937.4000
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms Of Use
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Sales Offices
    • Cookie Preferences
We use necessary cookies to make our site work. We'd also like to set up optional analytics cookies to help us improve it. We won't set optional cookies unless you enable them.
Decline Accept
We use necessary cookies to make our site work. We'd also like to set up optional analytics cookies to help us improve it. We won't set optional cookies unless you enable them.
Decline Accept