V18 - BIO - Lead 1
The highly variable interface between the implant wire and the bone tends to produce complex interactions during fatigue & durability bench testing.

V18 - BIO - Lead 2
Fig. 1: Biomedical Wire Implant, bend test at 10 Hz, 1-11 N, MTS Acumen Test System

V18 - BIO - Lead 3
Fig. 2: Small Aluminum Wire, bend test at  10 Hz, 1-11 N, MTS Acumen Test System

V18 - BIO - Lead 4 
Fig. 3: Small Aluminum Wire, bend test at 10 Hz, 1-2 N, MTS Acumen Test System

V18 - BIO - Video Graphic

Four-Point Bend Fatigue Testing for Small Extremity Implants

MTS Acumen™ Electrodynamic Test Systems enable medical device developers to accurately evaluate the unpredictable interfaces between metallic implants and bone tissue during pre-clinical bench testing.

Orthopaedic implantable devices for small extremity applications pose difficult testing challenges for device developers. Typically constructed from nickel-titanium alloy, these thin wire implants are anchored to a patient’s small joint, such as in a finger or toe. Difficulties arise because the interface between the implant and the bone is highly variable, and tends to produce complex interactions during fatigue & durability bench testing.

Device manufacturers need to analyze these interactions closely as they test different pairings of materials and bone. Sudden changes in specimen behavior due to degradation require the test system be able to maintain precise load control despite persistent stick/slip behavior. Without this ability, test systems are not able to generate the data developers need to characterize the implant’s durability and performance.

The small physical size of the implant further complicates the test which often requires a combination of low force (5 to 10 N, peak to peak), relatively high frequency (10 Hz) and low displacement (1 to 2 mm) for millions of cycles.

To perform the test with a conventional material test system, device developers often compromise by using a higher-than-ideal force (20 to 30 N, peak to peak) and a lower test frequency (2 Hz). These compromises mean that tests may yield less useful data and take more time. The interactions that developers wish to study in greatest detail may fall within the noise band of normal filtering. Slower tests can cost manufacturers’ critical weeks in time to market.

To deliver the performance that small extremity device developers demand, MTS recommends the MTS Acumen™ Electrodynamic Test System. Equipped with a four-point bend fixture and a 125 N load cell, this test system combines with MTS TestSuite™ Multipurpose Software and MTS FlexTest® digital controllers to create a fully integrated solution for maintaining accurate load control during bend tests on specimens with erratically preforming interfaces.

MTS Acumen systems are specifically designed to provide precise load and motion control, with a rigid load frame and direct-drive linear motor. These systems also offer unique integration with test software, which enables automated tuning. Automated tuning is helpful for unpredictable specimens because the software works independently to detect and enter specimen parameters. By “learning” what to expect from the specimen, the system is better able to recognize variations that cause uncertainty — and adapt accordingly during test execution.

A key component of the solution for this application is the MTS FlexTest® Digital Controller. This reliable control architecture is what enables the MTS Acumen system to deliver the frequency response necessary to maintain high accuracy while applying a low force at a high speed as interface stability varies. MTS FlexTest controllers represent decades of MTS expertise in solving industry- and application-specific load control challenges.

Improvements in test accuracy can be seen in the provided waveform graphs (Fig. 1, 2, 3), which show the cleaner waveforms developers can expect with MTS Acumen test systems.

Using MTS Acumen test systems for four-point bend tests of small extremity implants allows device developers to run the test they want, without making compromises in force, frequency or displacement.

Higher frequency testing may deliver a five-fold improvement in time to market, depending on the specimen. For example, completing five million cycles at 2 Hz takes nearly a month, while the same test run at 10 Hz can be completed in less than six days. Combined with a low force test that achieves the necessary realism, faster speeds help developers test more options with fewer test systems and respond faster to post-submission requests from the FDA and other regulators.


MTS Systems

14000 Technology Drive
Eden Prairie, MN USA

Tel: 952.937.4000
Tel: 800.328.2255
Fax: 952.937.4515
Email: info@mts.com